Prithviraj Chavan Calls for Inquiry Into Operation Sindoor and Pahalgam Attacks

Former Chief Minister of Maharashtra, Prithviraj Chavan, has called for a comprehensive inquiry into Operation Sindoor and the Pahalgam attacks, insisting that the public deserves clarity on the events. Speaking on December 17, 2025, Chavan emphasized the need for transparency regarding India’s military operations and the implications for national safety under the leadership of Prime Minister Narendra Modi.

Chavan’s comments followed his controversial assertion during a public event on December 16 in Pune, where he stated that India was “completely defeated” on the first day of Operation Sindoor. He claimed that during the initial aerial engagements on May 7, Indian aircraft were shot down, resulting in the Indian Air Force being grounded. “If any aircraft had taken off from Gwalior, Bathinda, or Sirsa, there was a high probability of being shot down by Pakistan,” he remarked.

His statements ignited a political firestorm, leading to accusations from various quarters. Chavan clarified that he did not intend to undermine the armed forces. Instead, he directed his questions to the political leadership, urging them to provide answers to the citizens. He cited Article 51A(h) of the Indian Constitution, emphasizing the duty of citizens to promote rational thinking and inquiry.

Political Reactions and Support

The fallout from Chavan’s remarks saw a mixed response from political leaders. While Sanjay Raut, a member of the Shiv Sena (Uddhav Balasaheb Thackeray faction), supported Chavan, claiming that the handling of Operation Sindoor was shrouded in mystery, others were less forgiving. Raut criticized the abrupt halt of military advances following a ceasefire call from U.S. President Donald Trump, describing it as a betrayal to the nation.

In contrast, Maharashtra’s Deputy Chief Minister Eknath Shinde condemned Chavan’s comments, suggesting they echoed sentiments aligned with Pakistan. Shinde accused Chavan of demoralizing the military and undermining national security. The ruling Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) also condemned Chavan, labeling him anti-national.

Chavan, responding to the backlash, reiterated that his comments were misinterpreted. He insisted that his concerns were directed at political leadership and not the military itself. “My question is to the political leadership,” he stated, reaffirming his respect for the armed forces.

The implications of Chavan’s statements and the call for an inquiry into Operation Sindoor and the Pahalgam attacks reflect ongoing tensions in Indian politics regarding national security and military strategy. The discourse has reignited debates about accountability and the role of political leaders in ensuring the safety and preparedness of the nation amidst complex geopolitical challenges.