Washington Sundar Struggles at No. 5 in India’s ODI Loss to South Africa

In the first One Day International against South Africa on November 30, 2025, at the JSCA International Stadium in Ranchi, Indian all-rounder Washington Sundar batted at No. 5 but struggled significantly. He managed to score only 13 runs from 19 balls, with a strike rate of 68.42, contributing to India’s difficulties during the match. Sundar was brought into the batting order due to the absence of Axar Patel, but his performance raised questions about the decision to promote him in a crucial position.

Challenges Faced by Sundar in the Middle Overs

When Sundar came to the crease, India was already facing pressure with the fall of their third wicket. The team needed stability to avoid a collapse, especially with a settled Virat Kohli at the other end. As the innings progressed, Sundar’s inability to rotate the strike became evident. He faced six balls without scoring before hitting a six, yet he continued to struggle against South African bowlers, particularly against pace.

During his brief innings, Sundar faced a total of 18 deliveries, of which seven were dot balls, and he only managed to score three singles. This performance was concerning, especially since Kohli was effectively rotating the strike on his end. The pressure was mounting, and Sundar’s inability to find form left India in a precarious position.

Analysis of Batting Order Decisions

Team India would typically benefit from having KL Rahul bat at No. 5, a position where he has proven his effectiveness. However, the decision to promote Sundar was influenced by the lack of left-handed batters to combat South Africa’s spinners. Although this strategy has previously worked well with Axar Patel, who has been effective against wrist and left-arm spinners, the Proteas fielded only one spinner in Prenelan Subrayen during this match.

In fact, Sundar’s record against pace bowling in the middle overs does not support his promotion to No. 5. He holds a strike rate of just 59.37 against pace in that phase, with a high dot ball percentage of 64.84. In his last two appearances at No. 4 in ODIs, he scored a mere 16 runs off 23 balls, averaging 8.00.

Although Sundar’s capabilities as a left-handed batter and spin bowler are notable, they do not necessarily translate to the role needed at No. 5. His recent batting form may be commendable, but Axar Patel’s experience and ability to rotate the strike are crucial in that position. Sundar’s ongoing development as a white-ball batter highlights the importance of placing players in roles that suit their strengths.

As the match unfolded, Sundar’s performance became a focal point for discussion among fans and analysts alike. The decision to promote him at a pivotal moment in the game did not yield the desired results, and it raises important questions about India’s batting strategy in future matches.