MLB Draft Day 1: Nationals Surprise with Willits, Mariners Shine

The first day of the 2025 MLB Draft concluded with a series of surprising selections, particularly the Washington Nationals’ choice of Eli Willits as the No. 1 overall pick. In a draft marked by uncertainty and no standout prospects, the Nationals opted for the high school shortstop, potentially allowing for financial flexibility in later rounds. The Seattle Mariners also made headlines, securing Kade Anderson, the top-ranked prospect, at No. 3.

The Nationals’ decision to select Willits raised eyebrows, as many analysts had not anticipated this move. Following the departure of former general manager Mike Rizzo, the team appeared to be taking a calculated risk. Willits, a 17-year-old, is viewed as a polished hitter who may fit well into their long-term plans.

At No. 2, the Los Angeles Angels chose Tyler Bremner, a pick that drew mixed reactions. Although Bremner was ranked much lower by some experts, his potential to impact the major league roster quickly aligns with the Angels’ strategy. ESPN analysts Alden Gonzalez, Jesse Rogers, and David Schoenfield discussed the implications of these early choices and their thoughts on standout selections throughout the evening.

Surprising Choices and Strategic Moves

The selections made by the Nationals and Angels reflect a broader trend in the 2025 MLB Draft. Gonzalez noted that the first two picks exemplify the draft’s overall uncertainty. The Nationals’ choice of Willits could save them money for future rounds, while the Angels’ pick of Bremner might provide a quicker return on investment.

Schoenfield highlighted that this draft lacked a clear-cut No. 1 pick, making teams more inclined to pursue underslot deals. This strategy can enable clubs to allocate funds towards high school talents who might otherwise choose college. The focus on financial strategy in the draft is not new but seems particularly pronounced this year.

The Rockies’ selection of Ethan Holliday at No. 4 was a sentimental choice, given his father, Matt Holliday, is a former star for the franchise. The move sparked excitement among fans and analysts alike. However, there were also head-scratchers, such as the Chicago Cubs’ selection of Ethan Conrad at No. 17, who had undergone shoulder surgery and was ranked lower by experts.

Highlights and Predictions

Among the standout picks was Billy Carlson going to the Chicago White Sox at No. 10. Rogers expressed enthusiasm for this choice, emphasizing that Carlson could be a top-five player despite the White Sox’s struggles last season. His defensive abilities are expected to complement the team’s pitching staff effectively.

Schoenfield pointed out that the Mariners’ ability to secure Anderson at No. 3 was a stroke of luck, given that they had hoped for him all along. His polished skills as a college pitcher could accelerate his trajectory to the majors, potentially allowing the Mariners to make roster upgrades during the trade deadline.

Looking ahead, both Gonzalez and Rogers identified Seth Hernandez, selected sixth by the Pirates, as a potential steal of the draft. Despite the inherent risks associated with high school pitchers, Hernandez’s athleticism and skill set could make him a valuable asset in the long term.

As the first day of the draft unfolded, it became clear that teams were embracing a new approach, focusing on the athleticism of high school players. The trend toward drafting younger talent reflects a shift in strategy, with an emphasis on potential rather than immediate impact.

The selections made on Day 1 will undoubtedly shape the future of these franchises. As teams continue to navigate the complexities of player development and financial strategy, the ripple effects of these early choices will be felt in the years to come.