Guardians Face Challenge After Emmanuel Clase’s Suspension

The Cleveland Guardians are grappling with a significant setback following the announcement from Major League Baseball (MLB) on July 10, 2023, that closer Emmanuel Clase has been placed on non-disciplinary paid leave. This move is part of an ongoing investigation into sports betting, and it has left the Guardians’ bullpen in a precarious position. While the long-term implications of Clase’s suspension remain uncertain, the immediate challenges are clear, prompting the team to look to other players to fill the void.

In Clase’s absence, three key players will be crucial for the Guardians as they aim to maintain their competitive edge.

Key Players Stepping Up

Cade Smith is expected to take on a more prominent role as the team’s closer. With a record of 2-3, a 3.02 ERA, and 3 saves in 44.2 innings, Smith has been a reliable relief pitcher this season. Although his current ERA appears inflated compared to his impressive 1.91 ERA from last season, this can be attributed to a challenging outing against the Tigers where he allowed four earned runs in a single inning. As Smith transitions into the closer role, his performance will be under scrutiny, especially since he will be eligible for arbitration after this season. The number of saves he accumulates could significantly influence his market value.

Another pitcher stepping into a higher-leverage situation is Nic Enright. Since making his MLB debut in May, Enright has fluctuated between the major leagues and Triple-A. He currently holds a record of 1-0 with a 2.41 ERA and 17 strikeouts in 18.2 innings. Enright has shown promise, particularly with a stellar 1.15 ERA over his last 15.2 innings. His recent performance included two scoreless innings against the Royals, highlighting his potential to thrive in high-pressure situations. As he gains experience, his role within the bullpen could expand significantly.

Lastly, Hunter Gaddis is another pitcher to watch. With a record of 1-1 and a 3.35 ERA, Gaddis has emerged as a solid option for the Guardians. Notably, he has yet to record a save in his MLB career, which is surprising considering his development into a trusted relief pitcher over the past year and a half. After recovering from an arm injury sustained on July 11, Gaddis has returned to form, pitching four scoreless innings. Despite a dip in some statistics compared to last year, he remains in the 90th percentile for hard-hit rate and chase rate, indicating his effectiveness against opposing batters.

Looking Ahead

The suspension of Emmanuel Clase is undoubtedly a blow to the Guardians, but the depth within their bullpen offers a glimmer of hope. As Cade Smith, Nic Enright, and Hunter Gaddis take on increased responsibilities, the Guardians will need to rally together to navigate this challenging period. Their performances over the coming weeks will be pivotal not only for the team’s immediate success but also for their individual careers as they adapt to new roles in the absence of one of their key players.

Ultimately, the Guardians have the talent necessary to remain competitive, but the coming games will test their resilience and adaptability in the face of adversity.