SGPC Member Challenges Punjab Government’s Meat Sale Ban in Amritsar

In Amritsar, a significant controversy has emerged following a notification from the Punjab government that designates the walled city as a ‘Holy City.’ Kiranjot Kaur, a member of the **Shiromani Gurdwara Parbandhak Committee (SGPC)**, has publicly condemned this decision, particularly its clause regarding the sale and consumption of meat.

Kaur took to social media to express her concerns, accusing the Punjab government of attempting to impose a “brahmanising” influence on the Sikh community. She pointed out that while **tobacco** and **kutha** (halal) meat are prohibited in Sikhism, the consumption of **jhatka** meat has historically been accepted. Kaur emphasized that alcohol and other intoxicants are also forbidden but insisted that the right to consume jhatka meat remains a legitimate aspect of Sikh culture.

Historical Context and Community Rights

Kaur referenced historical precedents to support her position, including the **Akali Dal’s** ‘Jhatka Conference’ held in **1935**. She noted instances where Sikh Gurus participated in hunting, citing a narrative involving **Guru Nanak Dev Ji**, who reportedly cooked deer meat during a solar eclipse at **Kurukshetra**.

In her statement, Kaur called upon the SGPC president to formally address the Punjab government, advocating for a return to the traditional Sikh code of conduct known as **maryada**. The Punjab government’s notification, issued on **December 15**, mandates an outright ban on the sale and use of meat within the municipal limits of Amritsar, but it fails to clarify which types of meat are affected by this restriction.

The notification issued by the **administrative secretary of the department of animal husbandry** indicates a broad prohibition:
“Request to issue prohibitory orders for sale and use of meat, etc., within the walled city of Amritsar and municipal limits of Sri Anandpur Sahib and Talwandi Sabo.”

Contrasting Perspectives on Meat Consumption

Conversely, former **Akal Takht jathedar** Bhai Ranjit Singh weighed in on the discussion, asserting that Gurbani does not permit the consumption of any meat, including jhatka. He noted that while Sikhs may have historically consumed meat out of necessity, such practices should not be condoned in contemporary times. Ranjit Singh challenged anyone who disagrees with this interpretation to engage in a televised debate, emphasizing the importance of adhering to the tenets of Sikhism.

This ongoing debate highlights the complex intersection of religious beliefs, cultural practices, and government regulations within the Sikh community. As discussions continue, the SGPC’s response and any potential amendments to the Punjab government’s notification may have lasting implications for the community’s rights and practices in Amritsar and beyond.